1958/59 Tommy Forde
1959/60 Jackie Patterson
1960/61 Sammy Hatton
1961/62 Albert Corry
1962/63 Ralph McGuicken
1963/64 Johnny Walker
1964/65 Sam Kydd
1965/66 Billy Nixon
1966/67 Dickie Sands
1967/68 Billy Stewart
1968/69 Billy McAvoy
1969/70 Billy Humphries
1970/71 Billy Nixon

1971/72 Billy Humphries
1972/73 Davy McCoy
1973/74 Maxie Patton
1974/75 Denis Matthews
1975/76 Ray Mowat
1976/77 Tom Armstrong
1977/78 Tom Armstrong
1978/79 Ray Mowat
1979/80 Ronnie Cromie
1980/81 Roy Walker
1981/82 Peter Craig
1982/83 John O'Connor
1983/84 Alan Dornan

1984/85 Alan Dornan
1985/86 Damien Byrne
1986/87 Damien Byrne
1987/88 Paul Kee
1988/89 Tom Pearson
1989/90 John Mullen
1990/91 Alan Fettis
1991/92 Noel Mitchell
1992/93 Darren Erskine
1993/94 Darren Erskine
1994/95 Kevin Brady
1995/96 Paul McBride
1996/97 Paul McBride

1997/98 No award

1998/99 Cullen Feeney
1999/00 Paul Curran

2000/01 John Bailie
2001/02 John Bailie

2002/03 Stephen Robertson
2003/04 Raymond Campbell

2004/05 Marty Hunter
2005/06 Marty Hunter
2006/07 Aaron McKee

2007/08 Darren Nixon
2008/09 Andy McDonald
2009/10 Kris Pike

2010/11 Aaron Kerr
2011/12 Ross Arthurs

2012/13 James Cully

2013/14 Willie Faulkner

2014/15 Greg Hall

2015/16 Ross Arthurs

2016/17 David McAllister

2017/18 Reece Glendinning

2018/19 Sam Johnston